Episode Transcript
Antifascist Dad Episode 60: Meet the Writers of the Lula Army Manual with Iago Ribeiro and Lucas Neckel
Matthew Remski: Hello, everyone. My name is Matthew Remski and this is episode 60 of the Antifascist Dad podcast. Meet the writers of the Lula Army Manual with Iago Ribeiro and Lucas Neckel. You can find me on Bluesky and Instagram under my name. I'm on YouTube and TikTok as antifascistdad. And the Patreon for this show is antifascistdadpodcast, where subscribers get early access to a second weekly episode, which this week is up tomorrow. That would be Wednesday. And it's a conversation with Sadie Mees, an anthropology scholar from Newfoundland who sailed with the Freedom Flotilla this past spring and was abducted in international waters by the IDF.
We talk about what got her onto that boat in her life, what we do when institutions fail, and also the strange feeling of coming home when the event itself is still continuing and why an activist can't really stop.
So that is up on Patreon tomorrow. That would be Wednesday.
In the show notes for this episode, you'll find links to all of the materials that we'll be discussing today, plus a link for my book. It's called Antifascist Dad: Urgent Conversations with Young People in Chaotic Times.
Okay, if any of you are following me on social media, you'll know. For the last two weeks, I've been obsessed with a viral guerrilla text called the Mini-Manual of Informational Insurgency. It is the theory handbook that has emerged from Lula's WhatsApp army and their historic electoral win on October 25.
And I had to talk to the two writers behind it as soon as I found out who they were. And here we are.
This is their first English language interview. We're revealing their names for the first time, I think.
And that's cool, because this manual, in my view, is a gem of Marxist realism, propaganda theory, psychoanalytic insight. And it's delivered with the intensity and clarity of a clinical session that. That I think changes something within people, certainly within me. It's the first contemporary revolutionary text I've come across that seems to not only meet, but outpace our technological and political moment.
Now, where is it coming from other than about 100 years of theory?
Here's the short timeline on how this weapon was made. If we go back to April of 2026, André Janones, a congressman, ex presidential candidate, creates the Exército do Lula WhatsApp channel. And it has about 50,000 followers before the first round of presidential voting. And that happens on the 4th of October. And in that first round, Flávio Bolsonaro, the crook, leads Lula 47.09% to 45.09% of valid votes.
And. And that's a huge problem.
And in light of this incredible urgent disappointment and terror, really, Janones turns the channel into a mobilization hub and it passes 1 million subscribers within two days.
On 7 October, after a video in which Lula asks supporters to join, setting a goal of 5, 10 million people, the channel reaches 2 million. And then fandoms, the fan societies attached to pop singers and various cultural enterprises and influencers begin coordinating alongside the WhatsApp group.
Between the 11th and 14th October, Flávio's campaign requests that the electoral court suspend the channel, and this happens twice for these pro forma violations. But it's restored on the night of the 14th of October, and it gains roughly 500,000 more subscribers within that same day. On the 21st of October, the channel reaches 7 million, and the 23rd to the 24th features Janones 24 hour livestream in which he assigns missions. This is right after the final presidential debate on TV Globo.
Now, what are the missions? The manual is in the show notes. You can read it in about 20 minutes and figure out what it's all about.
We covered the 12 points of the manual on a previous episode on Conspirituality Podcast, so I'll put that in the show notes. But on 25 October, it all pays off because Lula wins the runoff by more than 4 million votes. Now, as best as I can tell, about two days later, Iago and Lucas post the Mini-Manual of Informational Insurgency, or Janonism.
It's in Portuguese. First, this is a free 19 page PDF and a multilingual release follows the next day. The title of the text alludes to Carlos Marighella's 1969 Minimanual of the Urban Guerrilla.
And just to be clear, Janones has no part in writing this text.
And that brings us to today, where the manual is translated into at least 24 languages. It might be more, there might be another one being added. As I'm speaking now, it's raced around the world. Factions of the Democratic Socialists of America promote it. El País, Die Zeit and France 5 have covered it. Janones has shared the French edition and said that at least 70% of its content can be replicated in other countries.
So here is my discussion with Iago and Lucas, who open with a reflection on the figure of Janus which graces the cover of the manual. They talk about Janus as a way of describing the multilingual, layered and ambivalent nature of political action and perception. They say that it helps them avoid personifying the movement in André Janones. It helps them trace their intellectual heritage back to Brazilian Lacanian Magno Machado Dias, who holds that the unconscious is already merged with the media.
They argue a number of chilling but also bracing ideas.
They say that rational deliberation on platforms has collapsed. They say that argument alone cannot decide which account of reality prevails, so the left must build force in the infosphere.
They defend the value of informational contagion over what they describe as the catechetical habit that Marxists tend to have of explaining things harder even when nothing is getting through.
They describe outrage cycles as symptoms that serve Big Tech and and they call left pedantry, a kind of self serving purity.
They also frame anything goes, including AI imagery as a response to despair after a loss, such as they experienced in the first round.
It's not an ideal.
And then we discussed Naomi Klein's warning about mirroring the right. And then the almost esoteric subject of hyperstition, the idea or fiction that if it circulates through feedback loops, helps bring about the reality that it describes.
In one of the most moving moments for me of this interview, we talk about point 5 in the manual, and I'll just read that point straight. Through the influence of the Face, the French thinkers Deleuze and Guattari already knew the face is a machine.
In Brazil, Janonism produced the revolution of low profile users. Ordinary people began to display their political positions on their personal accounts.
Through political banners, photographs and watermarks. Politics acquired familiar faces beyond public figures and activists. A familiar face turns a message into a position openly assumed. It affects those around it and politicizes everyday relationships. Do not underestimate the power of showing up.
And then we talked about faciality and what that means in Brazil, a nation with an infinitude of faces.
Lucas and Iago, welcome to Antifascist Dad. Thanks so much for taking the time.
Lucas Neckel: Thank you so much for your space, Matthew.
Iago Ribeiro: Thank you, Matthew. I'm glad we're here.
Matthew Remski: And I want to say too, that I'm saying your names aloud and this constitutes a little bit of a reveal because up until a couple of days ago, I only knew you by your Twitter handles. But I suppose now you are out in the open and now we know who you are.
Lucas Neckel: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Iago Ribeiro: The low profile days are gone.
Matthew Remski: Okay, so we'll get to Low Profile in a moment, but first I want to establish the chain of command.
So are you observers to the Janonism movement? Or are you official propagandists?
Does André Janones tell you when you can sleep and eat?
Iago Ribeiro: Well, I would say that our allegiance lies more with Janus than with Janones at this point, but, yeah, I'm a good soldier as well.
Matthew Remski: When you say Janus, you are making reference to the figure on the cover of the mini manual, which is the figure of Janus. So what does that mean? What are we to make from the cover of the manual to begin with?
Iago Ribeiro: Well, Janus means for us a metaphor of the mirror.
This mirror, whose logic so important to think about the workings of the mind, the world, and of course, those of the platforms as well.
Janus is the God with two faces. He's always looking in opposite directions at once.
And I think Janus is also a good way not to personify Janonism too much. You know, I think that what happened is much bigger than the man Janones.
And by that I don't mean to underplay his role, but quite the contrary. But I think we will talk more about Janus through our interview.
Matthew Remski: What you're saying is you've discovered a kind of archetype that can represent the leading theorization of this project that's not really associated to this person or to his charisma.
Iago Ribeiro: That's right. That's right.
We are trying to think about it in more abstract ways, not personifying it, because it's a major phenomenon.
Matthew Remski: Okay, now just to clear out another abstraction, Would you say that Nossa Senhora Aparecida is concerned about your Marxist errors?
Iago Ribeiro: Well, you know, we have this online friend who uses Nossa Senhora as her nickname, and I think she's not concerned about it at all.
Lucas Neckel: Also doing a very good job on translations. Recently, Serbian translation was made by her Mercury Sky Blue on Twitter.
Matthew Remski: Oh, wow,
Lucas Neckel: her nickname.
Matthew Remski: So this is very interesting because I would imagine that even with some kind of symbology or a language like as is provided by Nossa Senhora, you find ways of doing cultural translation between, you know, fellow European or fellow global Catholics as well.
Lucas Neckel: This is a Brazilian special way.
Matthew Remski: Let me just pause there and ask. Is there a television in the background somewhere?
Iago Ribeiro: Propaganda car. Pass my street right now. But it's.
Matthew Remski: Oh, propaganda car.
Iago Ribeiro: Streets. We have this problem here in Brazil.
Lucas Neckel: Street journalism.
Matthew Remski: Okay, street journalism. Okay.
All right, next question. Was the mini manual your idea together? What happened that gave you the sense that you had an exportable theory to offer?
Iago Ribeiro: This idea occurred to us when. While we were amid the mobilization.
But actually, since I met Lucas.
We have always been talking about theoretical questions, doing exchanges about concepts, experiences and all. And so when suddenly all this process, this whole process was triggered by the catastrophic results of the first round of our elections, but also by Janones himself.
We decided to join the mobilization. And it was kind of a logical consequence to start talking about that and eventually start writing about the questions that Janonism raised for us.
And, I mean, it didn't come out of nowhere, actually.
We. I think we already had at hand the conceptual tools to reach a good understanding and a description of what was going on here.
And to be frank, in the end, it all comes down to psychoanalysis.
Lucas Neckel: That's our common ground
Iago Ribeiro: and to this specific.
Yeah, common ground and this specific current of psychoanalytical theory advanced by a very important Brazilian thinker called Magno Machado Dias.
We understand that the mind, the unconscious, is always already prosthetic, always already merged with technologies in the media and so on.
And this is how people's realities are shaped.
So I would say that not only is the medium the message, as McLuhan has said, but the media produce reality as well.
Matthew Remski: Can I just clarify? You both share a background in psychoanalysis or psychoanalytic education?
Lucas Neckel: We met through psychoanalysis.
Iago Ribeiro: That's right.
Matthew Remski: This thinker that you've referred to, who I do not think is cited in the manual, is this somebody who took the ideas of Deleuze and Guattari and Lacan before them and advanced those ideas?
Iago Ribeiro: That's right. He was actually a very close follower of Lacan.
He studied with Lacan at France, and then he came back to Brazil and started thinking his own thing.
Matthew Remski: A few more sort of technical details on the production aspect. Who all is doing the translations and how are they doing the translations and how many translations are there now?
Lucas Neckel: We made the first French translation.
A friend did the Japanese and English ones, and other friends translated it into Guarani.
The other translations just started appearing out of nowhere. At this point, there are about 24 translations.
Thanks also to Nossa Senhora.
We know people at a university in Korea receive it from their own department by email.
We got in touch with political parties in Kyrgyzstan that started translating it into Russian and discussed it.
Matthew Remski: I might have been the contact point for that, because I think I received a message from somebody in Kyrgyzstan asking for the manuals. And then maybe they found you through Twitter.
Lucas Neckel: Also, big shout out to Esercito della Sinistra in Italy for making the first Italian version. They were among the first to officially adopt the manual, along with the Japanese Communists and La France Insoumise.
So big shout out to these guys.
It also had a big response in Poland, Indonesia.
We have no idea who started those translations.
We have no idea either how many downloads there have been. We can only guess.
Matthew Remski: I was going to ask about that because Google Drive doesn't tell you. Right. It
Iago Ribeiro: got out of control.
Lucas Neckel: Yeah. It's a shame we cannot track that at all. But a lot, probably.
Iago Ribeiro: It's completely out of control.
Lucas Neckel: So, talking about this, a professor, I think, from Canada also pointed out something I find really important and still under theorized, that we'll eventually have to reckon with this new form of guerrilla publishing enabled by highly capable LLMs.
Matthew Remski: Right.
Lucas Neckel: I think something just begun here whose consequences we can't yet measure at all. We will have to deal with it in the future.
Matthew Remski: That's one of the things that I think just on almost, since I'm speaking to psychoanalytic people, almost on an unconscious level, has been so thrilling to me about this, because I'm 54, I've been writing and publishing for 35 years.
And my first publications came out of a kind of 1970s DIY independent press kind of milieu.
And the actual labor involved in getting something printed and distributed and read by other people is so incredibly arduous in this prior age.
But I recognize, I open up your manual in its PDF form, and I recognize that this is something that could have come off of a Press in 1932 or 1964 or 1978.
And it looks the same, it feels the same, and yet it is able to be distributed in an almost frictionless manner. And I think, like, that's just extraordinary to me.
Lucas Neckel: It has an uncanny old school aspect to it, doesn't it?
Matthew Remski: Yeah,
Lucas Neckel: I see it too. But this time of, like, slow publishing, when it comes to manuals, guerrilla manuals, it's all over.
Like,
Matthew Remski: it's over. Right. I think both of you. I don't know who's making all of the memes, but I think both of you are playing on the retro feel of the event. Right. There is a number of. And I mean, maybe this is some Catholic aesthetic influence as well, but there are a number of kind of heroic renaissance, like portraits of Lula with Godzilla beams of light coming out of his eyes, but he's trampling all of the fascist leaders of the world and he's holding the book aloft and the frame is vibrating as though the monsters are stepping on the earth.
And that feels like it's coming out of the past as well, oddly. And yet it's Beaming around the world at the speed of light.
Lucas Neckel: Yeah, we just stole it from reactionary meme scene. Like they are all doing that. So we just mirrored for our side. They are still very attached to these herculean archetypes and all of this corny stuff.
So let's go.
Iago Ribeiro: They are all very male and strong and they destroy everything.
Matthew Remski: Okay, I just have to say, I mean, I'll publish some video clips of this, but for the listeners. This is the first time that I'm meeting Iago and Lucas. And I must say that these are very, I would say, gentlemen, they are calm.
They are not muscular Marxists.
And so learning that they're also both students of psychoanalysis, I'm realizing that there is a biting humor and irony under every appropriation of this kind of aggressive imagery.
Lucas Neckel: Yeah, of course
Iago Ribeiro: we have to laugh about it. And laughing is a very Brazilian thing also.
Lucas Neckel: And also part of the deal
Iago Ribeiro: to be able to laugh about serious things. And
Lucas Neckel: laughter and dissemination are on the same matrix. They go side by side. We know it by clinical experience, maybe.
Matthew Remski: That sounds like it's very deep. You're saying that the thing that makes you laugh is also the thing that allows for the propagation or the contagion of an idea.
Lucas Neckel: It opens a door, obviously, like even we can say in a simple way to someone that has a little bit of psychology concepts in mind. It breaks some defenses.
Matthew Remski: Speaking of breaking defenses, and who gets to do that?
Are you a vanguard?
And what is the relationship between the manual and the rank and file of the Lula army?
Iago Ribeiro: Wait a minute. The car is in the streets again,
Lucas Neckel: we are forged in propaganda, bro.
Matthew Remski: Amazing.
Iago Ribeiro: Janonism is everywhere. But I would say.
But we are a very specific kind of observers.
That's because through all those weeks of heavy mobilization, we were both soldiers in the sense that we were indeed following the commands coming from Janones through Lula's army. But we were also constantly exercising some kind of detachment from that, exercising an analytic stance. You know, the vibes were very intense during those weeks. So this detachment was a way of taking a breath, to not fully identify with that and to be able to make some sense out of it. So I think the mini manual.
The relationship between the mini manual and the army is that the manual draws on some theoretical tools to give some intelligibility not only to the army, but to all the contexts and the assumptions that preceded. I mean, all these theory of informational trances and reality shaping that we put at the manual. And maybe that kind of observation explains the huge impact and the reverberation that the manual is producing worldwide.
Because suddenly everybody wanted to know what kind of miracle happened in Brazil.
And there was this manual trying to explain it briefly.
Matthew Remski: You pack a lot of information into the introduction, which is only a few pages long, and I'll just remind the listeners that this manual is maybe 15 pages or something like that, maybe less.
Was it 2,000 words or maybe three? I don't know,
Iago Ribeiro: 19 pages, I think.
Matthew Remski: The North Star of that introduction, the final beat is that you say the dream of a digital public sphere for deliberation through rational arguments is over.
Only a force sufficient to produce hegemony in the infosphere can confront the political processes preying on what little civilization we have left.
So we all know, I think we can all feel that deliberation has failed.
But can you walk us through how you believe that happened?
Lucas Neckel: I think it happened through a change in the conditions under which truth is produced and shared.
Like we say, the dream of rational deliberation assumed at some point that beneath our disagreements there was a sort of common ground. And this common ground was made of enough shared facts, stable institutions and trust in argument for people to be persuaded and to reach a provisional consensus. A common 20th century motive. I would say so. We know that that ground was never as neutral or universal as the ideal suggested.
But it gave back in the day, public debate, a supposedly recognizable form.
But with the arrival of the 21st century, the speed and scale of information have completely unsettled the institutions and frameworks that used to stabilize that ground.
Yeah, we are increasingly aware that political accounts are on reality, are constructed and so on. But that awareness has not produced agreement about which of these accounts to trust.
So instead we read it as competing formations that circulate, driven by force. We wrote in the manual a DDOS attack form.
The result is not simply that, oh my God, nowadays people believe fake news and false, false things. The thing is that argument alone cannot decide the products of reality. That's why we speak of hegemony in the infosphere.
Matthew Remski: Yeah,
Lucas Neckel: the question, the real question, is how affirmation gains enough force to organize what people perceive, repeat and act upon.
We will develop definitely this politically and theoretically this in our book.
Matthew Remski: I want to make a meta comment though here, which is that it seems there are categories of life to which this is and isn't applied. So for instance, the three of us, I think, are now deliberating. I think we can deliberate because beneath the distance between us, between Toronto and Rio, beneath our whatever language barrier we have, we, I think, share a Literature and a heritage of leftist and Marxist analysis. We have, you know, there's a bookshelf behind you, Iago, and I imagine that many of those titles are in my home as well.
And so I think we're talking about where discourse crosses over some sort of threshold into the public sphere, where this kind of deliberation becomes illegible, where it cannot be a weapon of force.
Is that a fair way of saying it?
Iago Ribeiro: I would say that maybe it is possible to play this game of deliberation among a small number of people.
But even there, psychoanalysis always remind us that we must be aware of the fact that desire and the unconscious, they are at play at every level.
And anyone who lives among people day by day, even with a lot of common ground, knows very well that how hard it is to make arrangements and make them work.
But of course, things become much more complicated and complex when we're talking about thousands or millions of people interacting through these platforms that are far from neutral.
Actually they favor permanent excitation, conflict, the formation of bubbles and so on.
So I think the big problem with continuing to think politics on social media in terms of deliberation is that while you are, while you think you're playing one game, you're actually being played by another game, a very different game.
And more than this, in the actual game, you're being badly beaten, even while you're making the soundest arguments.
So this is a kind of mindset that is not effective anymore. And I think it's very clear for everyone right now.
Matthew Remski: Why do you think liberals in particular get very, very uncomfortable around this idea that the sphere of deliberation has collapsed?
Iago Ribeiro: I think liberals are so offended by this realization because they are deeply, deeply used to seeing themselves as a kind of reservoir of moral superiority, of rationality, and it's very hard to give up this position.
And actually many of them would prefer to see the world burning rather than engage in more effective ways of acting.
And we see it very clearly when so-called liberals, democrats on the left, they react to the mini manual or to Janonism as a threat, even when they have no idea how to counter the far right movements that are rising everywhere in the world.
So I think they want to keep their hands clean while leaving the field open to fascistic uprisings.
Matthew Remski: The downstream effect of accepting that deliberation has collapsed in the public sphere is that there is an implication for the autonomous subject, for the person who holds that value.
And in Section nine you say that the autonomous subject is no longer really the model of the political actor.
You Say that soldiers must momentarily suspend their critical consciousness and act as amplification nodes rather than behaving as the Enlightenment autonomous subjects that they are used to perceiving themselves as. Now, there's a lot of people who would worry, and I think you're referring to this, that turning activists into automated slogan repeating nodes erodes the critical thinking, you know, required for long term liberation. And so what would you say to them?
Iago Ribeiro: Well, I think I would say that if they have something better in mind that is indeed effective in interrupting the rise of this highly regressive movements, it would be my pleasure to listen to them.
I mean, we are never playing in ideal conditions.
I don't think Janonism is an ideal of political action, but that's what we've got for now, given the conditions.
And what we try to do in the manual is try and describe the situation we are.
And unfortunately, people in general are already seized by the trances induced by the platforms.
So Janonism is about turning this given situation in favor of a political project more attuned to at least what I consider to be.
A better political project, more attuned to better existential conditions.
But yeah, if we weren't under the yoke of these platforms, I think it would be a whole different game and maybe we wouldn't have to lower our standards so much to win.
Lucas Neckel: So we had some kind of funny critique that just attacked the manual, saying things like, oh, what about tech sovereignty in Brazil? We can live in Janonism forever, and so on and so on. And obviously no one here is an idiot at this point, but we can see that some of these papers and Instagram posts were just reading just to bitch about it. You know, it is not like we are giving up of the utopia horizon or something like that.
Matthew Remski: Yeah, what explains psychoanalytically the perpetual confusion between tactics and essence? Because I think that's what we're getting at is that the person encounters the manual and they say, oh, is this who I'm meant to be now?
And I think you are saying, no, this is how you were to recognize your situation and respond to it.
Lucas Neckel: Yeah, this is a huge symptom to take this.
Like, we have a lot of ways to approach this, the relationship of the left with authoritarianism, the schisms in the left. But I think there are also a lot of personalistic motives in play.
Matthew Remski: Okay, so another very large philosophical point that you press involves disciplining a more traditional, or I would say pre digital Marxist habit.
The manual calls to eradicate the missionary and catechetical spirit of traditional Marxism Arguing that transmitting consciousness or transforming consciousness has collapsed and it has to be replaced by contagion. So this is somewhat of the same issue.
But what do we mean by this missionary and catechetical spirit? What does it feel like and how does it play out in practice?
Lucas Neckel: That was the first, definitely the point that provoked the strongest reactions and we expected that. It is the most straightforward psychoanalytic element in manual.
Matthew Remski: And you put it in capitals, I think
Lucas Neckel: so these.
Matthew Remski: As if it wasn't going to be provocative enough.
Lucas Neckel: So this catechetical, I'm pronouncing it right.
Okay,
Iago Ribeiro: yes.
Lucas Neckel: It comes from the naive idea that political change depends on bringing people to reality or truth, if you want.
Matthew Remski: Right.
Lucas Neckel: If they can be taught to see the real situation, they will become conscious and act accordingly to this new revelation.
So you have one person that already knows another has yet to understand, and the right explanation will bridge the gap.
You know, So I read in, in the comments of your video about dunking a brilliant clinical confession. The guy wrote something like, I know it isn't working, but if I just find the right words, they finally understand.
Man. I hear this in clinic like every day.
Every day for different situations, love affairs and stuff. So it's all over.
You begin to treat like disagreement as lack of information or failure to grasp what you already know. And even when persuasion fails, you have the drive to explain harder, you know?
So calling for contagion means.
Contagion means that we take seriously that politics moves in other dimensions and there are transferential or bond related issues we must analyze in politics. The turnaround in the Brazilian elections can be a case study for this. We think so. Contagion.
Damn. It describes a process in which formations affect and alter one another through contact.
So what circulates in the infosphere is, you know, never a pure idea or unchanged in transit. Even political teaching, political missionary teaching is caught up in the attachments and symptoms it hopes to transform.
So I think it's that way without this specific topic in the manual.
Matthew Remski: I think that just to maybe slow down and add some a little bit of simplicity or accessibility to the framework that you're bringing.
What I understand from this approach is that prior to the attempt to articulate an explanation, a political theory to another person, prior to taking your own position and saying to the person that you would like to convince or you would like to grow a bond with that there are an almost infinite number of pre existing points of contact that that person might have with the new idea or that might block their reception of what you need to say, or what you want to.
So is part of what you're saying that ideology and political belief and commitment is very, very richly and in a layered manner, it's formed in many, many different ways, and that it is quite naive, it's an illusion to think that the sort of correct set of statements as the commenter is hoping to manage, is going to break through all of those layers of influence.
Lucas Neckel: Yeah, I loved your emphasis on prior. Yes, it is. It's a shame English doesn't have the word vínculo. Magno talked about vincular. We can translate it as bond. So what I was saying about bond related stuff, it is something like that.
Start again. Contagion.
Contagion comes first.
And in the infosphere, sometimes it is the only thing that matter at all.
Matthew Remski: And one is not going to understand that, for instance. Or one might understand that, but if one studies Lacan, for example, one understands that language comes far after the question of how the baby understands itself as being a subject. The baby, for instance, looks in the mirror and for a while does not recognize that they are independent and that at a certain point they recognize that they are independent. And at that moment something crystallizes about their reality, their subjectivity, and that begins to frame the way they will understand language or learn language or acquire concepts.
And so those very subtle and pervasive experiences of life are setting. Are those the bonds that you're talking about? Is that vínculo?
Lucas Neckel: Part of it, yeah, part of it. Part of it. When you talk about language, we are already in a secondary level of arrangements,
Matthew Remski: but
Lucas Neckel: yeah, it's part of it. We are neck deep in the symptoms of our native tongues, for example, we are neck deep in the symptoms of what you are calling ideology, for example. We are always neck deep in it.
So, yeah, part of it.
Iago Ribeiro: And I would say that Magno emphasizes a lot, a lot of things that come prior to language in the sense that, for example, we are mammals as well.
And these conditions make us very prone to a lot of kinds of trances and the platforms, they know that as well, and they take advantage out of it.
They know how to entertain the monkeys that we are also prior to language.
Matthew Remski: I want to ask if you feel, and this is not to criticize your intellectual heritage, but given the fact that Lacan and psychoanalysis can be very complex, do you think that something like attachment theory provides the same sort of insight, or a similar insight into what exists prior to our.
Not prior to our social relations, but what our social relations are built upon? So I think it's not hard for most people to understand that they have a way of relating to others that is either avoidant or anxious and that they either move towards others or they move away from others. Like that seems to be very au courant. It seems to be very much a lingua franca of even popular psychology. Do you think that that is also a good way of beginning to break this notion that actually if I have the best ideas and the best sentences organized, then I will convince somebody to be a progressive voter?
Lucas Neckel: We could talk all day about this, but I can say that when we talk about these types, we are already in a psychological framework, you know, when we talk about bond, we are still one step back, you know,
Matthew Remski: before.
Lucas Neckel: Before, yeah.
So psychological types are already like sedimented forms of relationship, you know, so.
And it works. It works to frame something here or there, you know?
Matthew Remski: Yeah,
Lucas Neckel: but it is just like when someone maps this, he's looking at like specific historic crystallization of lots of types of relation, including bonds going on.
So you are already in a deeper level of abstraction. We are trying to think back.
Matthew Remski: One thing that I wanted to ask you about contagion is that if it replaces the slower and more pedantic forms of political education, what are the risks?
Lucas Neckel: Bad news, it already happened.
So talking about this, people often mistake description for prescription, right? When we talk about euphoria, it is a signifier that appear a lot as substitutes.
Some people even thought it was a claim we made in the manual, but not at all. The manual starts from the fact that this shift you mentioned has already happened. Platform dynamics, repetition, coordinated circulation.
And the far right before us has learned to use it very effectively.
Like Bolsonaro was like a pop show stupid guy that really started to make his name through Internet memes like the Boss and crappy shit like that.
So the question we started to develop is how to act in a political terrain already shaped by contagion without obviously simply surrendering that terrain to the right, like some people. Oh no, X is ruled by Elon Musk. Let's find a safe place to talk. Okay. And leave
Matthew Remski: Mastodon.
Lucas Neckel: Yeah, and leave it to the. To the right then.
No, no good idea at all to leave a territory for your enemy.
Matthew Remski: So we'll get into the tactics in a moment, but I just want to prefigure that by saying that with the metaphor of contagion.
I think that if you tell the progressive or the leftist that they already inhabit an environment of contagion, the first response is to say, oh well, we need inoculation we need a vaccine, right? We need to protect ourselves in some way. And actually you go the other way, you say, no, actually you have to produce your own virus.
Lucas Neckel: I couldn't say it better, bro.
Yeah, that's it.
Matthew Remski: That brings me to Naomi Klein, because now we'll talk about mirroring.
She warned in this really interesting, fascinating, beautiful book called Doppelganger, that the right wing mirror world distorts reality into this reactionary hall of mirrors in which fascists can very easily pretend plausibly to care for workers or the environment.
And it's plausible because the neoliberals are failing.
Now, your principle number eight in the manual calls for mirroring opposition memes, formats and messages with the signs reversed.
So walk me through how Janonist mirroring breaks the opponent's mirror, rather than simply trapping progressive or leftist activists deeper inside corporate platform logic.
Iago Ribeiro: Well, I would say that there are at least two ways of thinking about the mirror.
Naomi Klein is right when she points out that the mirror may be kind of trap when it's used and understood as a kind of trance-inducing mechanism, as we would say.
And the left is not above doing this same thing. It's a real, an actual risk.
But the mirror may be something more radical, more productive as well.
And this is where the image, the metaphor of Janus serves us, because the mirror interests us as a way of going beyond the mere opposition, to exercise a kind of third position, which is not at all a third way in the political sense, but the possibility for our psyche to escape being trapped, even if just momentarily, but escape some trances that are offered to, or even imposed on us.
So it's a way to break free from a situation and to be able to come up with a new one, a new situation.
And this is a personal and a permanent exercise. And this is what psychoanalysis as we understand it is all about.
The car is here again.
Wait just some seconds. Isn't
Matthew Remski: that funny? Just as you say, this is what psychoanalysis is all about. And the car goes by unintelligibly, like the subconscious, like yelling in your ear.
Iago Ribeiro: It never stops talking.
But I would ask how we can make new kind of politics out of this, but for me it's still an open question.
And it seems to me as well that if we have a future as a species, that's the way forward. But for now we're seeing the logic of mirroring being deployed in this struggle, in these conditions, under the colonization of the infosphere by these big platforms.
And mirroring is used as a way of Neutralizing the far right as they try to push their captures, which I think is very impressive. But honestly, we still have a long way to go with the mirrors.
Matthew Remski: The other platform that I wanted to address, which is Principle two, it reminds me of this instinct that I think people have when they see their opponent making a statement that they know is incorrect, that they know is reactionary, that they know will create the conditions for a more repressive world.
And what they want to do is they want to go to the person's post and they want to comment.
They want to, as we said about the commenter before, they want to come up with the exact explanation that will somehow free the original poster of their delusion.
But the problem is that the post is a spatial experience as well, right?
The account is my page, and I think the poster, whoever has given the original message, they regard that space as kind of their home, or perhaps their.
Their own, their forum.
And your entrance is going to be unwelcome to begin with.
You were not invited there. Paradoxically, it's public and you're supposed to engage, but you're not invited there.
And you think that that will be an effective way and that maybe even if you're as polite as possible, as you enter, you take off your shoes, you try to reflect all of their arguments back to them, you try to say, I see what your point is, but I would like to counter it with this.
It still amounts to you are trying to go to their house and lay a fart in their hallway and think that it's going to be effective.
And this is a very deep instinct that I think people have online.
And what you are saying in the manual and what Janones is saying all the time is you do not reply to, even to mock or to debunk. You do not outrage, post against opposition content, and you have to ignore it. And so I'm wondering, how do you begin to train people outside of clinic? I suppose to suppress the itches that they have to express outrage, which the algorithms just convert into this free fuel for far right personalities.
Lucas Neckel: I'm laughing because Janones almost had another heart attack over it.
He sent an audio like, are children using cell phones nowadays?
Because there must be only children in this group.
You are always reacting and stuff. He was almost screaming in the audience, stop this. Why you do this?
So honestly, I have no idea how to train activists to suppress this impulse or instinct. We don't even know if it is really trainable. Time will tell, but it must be tied to something larger so we can do some speculation, because outrage can feel like virtue. You know,
Matthew Remski: it
Lucas Neckel: gives us an immediate payoff.
We get to display our indignation. We feel affirmed by our own side. And by reacting, that is the trap. We stay attached to the provocation, caught in this open end circuit. It's a little symptom, as I said, moved by desire as every other symptom.
So the platform turns that little itch, I love that metaphor, into engagement, then feeds it back to you.
So in this sense, we joked, me and Iago, that the army of the big tech is already there, all of us, whenever the algorithm can make us react, we are part of the army of the big tech.
Obviously, we know that hate and love are bound to the same matrix that we can name as fascination.
It's all about fascination. Like the medusating spirit of the thing.
Iago Ribeiro: Precisely.
Matthew Remski: Okay, you also say that we must abolish intellectual pedantry and sectarianism by adopting an anything goes stance.
And this means utilizing AI generated kitsch. It means using shitposts, thirst traps, pop culture edits.
I need to ask, why does the pedantry exist? And what does it function? How does it function? What does it do?
Iago Ribeiro: I would say that this pedantry serves only itself.
Actually, it's part of this, all this scratching that you were talking about.
It's the symptomatic functioning of the left. Again, we're talking about it a lot today, because people, the people we call right wing, are far too used to lowering their own standards to win, if they have any standards, but they are winning.
And if it weren't for Lula here in Brazil, in our case, in his popular appeal, I think we would be in a much worse situation right now, because this leftist fixation on purity actually hinders its possible effectiveness in political action, especially when we're talking about the infosphere mediated by those platforms. Because as Lucas has said, if you fall into a trap, into a provocation, a rage, bait, thirst trap, whatever it is, you are working for the platform. And when you're working for the platform, you are working for the far right that knows very well how to take advantage of how the platforms work, how the algorithms work, the car, again, all day long.
But again, I think the enjoyment for this, This left wing people addicted to pedantry, their enjoyment comes from assuming that they have this moral high ground.
And it is the perfect formula for staying trapped in your own bubble and for staying trapped in the dynamics, the algorithmic dynamics that goes.
That goes on in those platforms.
And besides that, the platforms limit the reach of content that is too intellectualized. You have to transpose it to more suitable formats if you want to reach people. This is Janonism lesson one.
And even when you try to translate and to transpose it, even then it won't be so viral as more trashy content that has algorithmic appeal.
But for the Janonist strategy to be effective and actually take hold of the infosphere, people must let go of all the solemnity and forced seriousness when it comes to politics.
That's why memes, fandoms, shitposting, and so on.
All this stuff matters so much.
It's not the carefully crafted primer or the video of someone earnestly venting the risks for democracy.
That's not what will reach people. You can do that too. But anything goes, right? But if that were all we had, we would be screwed.
Matthew Remski: You know, I have to ask you whether or not there's an essay by Eve Sedgwick that is popular in Brazil or known to you, where she describes paranoid reading versus generative reading or reparative reading.
Have you heard of this?
Lucas Neckel: Never heard of it,
Iago Ribeiro: no.
Matthew Remski: Okay, so she starts with Paul Ricoeur's observation that within leftist discourse, we inhabit a hermeneutics of suspicion.
Lucas Neckel: Yeah.
Matthew Remski: And this stems from the triumvirate of Nietzsche, Freud and Marx, who all are extremely suspicious of the structures of reality as they're constructed, and that that taints every interaction with a kind of skepticism and doubt.
Or it can.
And one of the most impressive things about this essay that I think she communicates is that we do this.
We do this in order to avoid humiliation after our anticipated loss.
So if we can be very serious about what the conditions are and how terrible everything is, if we can really, really raise the alarm, then afterwards we can say, oh, I told you, I told you. And we will not have to suffer the humiliation of having been fooled.
And this is what I'm thinking of as you're describing.
The pedantry and the seriousness.
Iago Ribeiro: Yeah, of course. I think there will be the time when all these people will be like, I told you Janonism was wrong all along.
We are going to see it for sure.
Matthew Remski: Okay, so one thing that, as you know, I've engaged with this manual as a kind of like, cultural translator in a series on Instagram called Janonism for Gringos.
Iago Ribeiro: I think you'll know more about the manual than all of us.
Lucas Neckel: High Pattern Guy
Iago Ribeiro: at this point. High
Lucas Neckel: Pattern Guy on the army, Like General?
Matthew Remski: I don't think so. I don't think so.
But one thing that I can say is that the thing that the gringos really don't like about this manual, really are not happy with, especially unhappy with, is with strategic AI usage.
And so what do you have to say to them in your best kind of like psychoanalytic manner?
Iago Ribeiro: Well, this question opens a lot of other questions, but I would say that the problem regarding AI I see it not, but the technology as such, which I find very useful in many ways and more people use it than are willing to admit.
Actually, I think the problem with AI is that the technology is still in the hands of just a few big companies.
And I think AI should be really open and that the left is mistaken in its prevailing Luddite approach, so to speak.
I think we should struggle to seize it for us, for our own use, and that this is not incompatible to other issues like energy consumption, data centers and so on.
And as far as I can see, this reactive stance that prevails in the left only benefits the big companies.
Matthew Remski: Yeah,
Iago Ribeiro: I think it would be much nicer to burst their bubble.
Matthew Remski: I guess structurally it's similar to I'm really going to leave Twitter.
Iago Ribeiro: Yeah, of course, you're leaving the territory behind and the field open to the adversaries.
That's it,
Lucas Neckel: that's it.
Iago Ribeiro: You're leaving it all to them.
Matthew Remski: One comment that I've yet to make on Instagram about this specifically is that I think, I don't know if this is in play in Brazil to the same extent, but in North America there is a very strong argument that is deployed by neoliberal logic that says you are personally responsible for the destruction of the materials that you use.
And so this is an argument that's deployed in discussions around pollution or recycling, or what kind of appliance you have in your house, or whether you have a car or not, or things like that. Now, of course we can all make as sensible choices as we can, but the thing that comes up to me about the comparison between socialist activists using AI to make memes versus Palantir using AI to target people in Palestine is that the use differential is enormous.
Like the amount of energy and resources and compute and water that you would use to make those herculean images of Lula stomping on the fascists of the world. Very, very tiny application.
But the usage that actually programs the flight of a bomber jet is logarithmically larger.
But somehow the instinct is to say, oh, I really must never use even a small portion of the thing my enemy uses.
Lucas Neckel: This is the old question, like ideology makes you think that your Slow bath is the cause of water consumption and not like, agribusiness.
This painting, you know, if you compare, it's absurd. Like, yeah, we are very aware that our mini manual cheap GIF memes don't use as much as Palantir stuff. So, yeah, this is. We. We tend to.
We. We saw you. You said North America, but Japanese guys were like, very, very, very, very, very preoccupied about it. They even wrote a second version of the manual, like abolishing the AI part. Yeah. Oh,
Matthew Remski: really?
Lucas Neckel: Yeah, they did it. They did it in a Japanese version, like substituting AI for, like, hand drawings. And so
Iago Ribeiro: let's correct one little thing in the mini manual. That's what they did.
Matthew Remski: Yeah. So how are you disciplining those heretics, my soldiers?
Iago Ribeiro: We have no control over their mini manual. I think this point, the mini manual has its own life.
Lucas Neckel: I think they have to get a shock like the first round of our election to wake up to this.
I think they.
Iago Ribeiro: Then they will understand what anything goes is all about.
It comes out of despair. I would say we were in a very bad situation after the first round in our elections, and we had to do something.
We had to use what we had at hand.
Matthew Remski: Here's the next theme that I want to ask about, because I find this extraordinary, and I know that it is not original to you, but I had not come across it before.
You use the phrase memetic hyperstition.
And my understanding of hyperstition is so far that it is the activated intuition around a certain momentum or direction that creates an affect. And that affect can be enthusiastic or it can go in another direction.
But you describe in the manual that you are trying to create positive memetic hyperstition. And this seems like a very esoteric principle, especially when you describe the context of genones acting as a kind of prophet of the prefiguration of Lula's win before it happens, while you're in a terrible place of despair.
And my background is in religious extremism and New Age thought.
And so this is very, I don't know, close to home for me, because this is the kind of thing that if you're using in a political direction, that I approve of, but I also have seen that it can have some very distracting effects. And so I'm just wondering if you can walk us through what hyperstition means for you.
Lucas Neckel: So El País, and in very important Spanish journal, called us Lula's wizards. Just put this on my tombstone at this point.
So, okay, no talking. Seriously. Hyperstition traces back as you research to our specific reading of the CCRU, the Cybernetic Culture Research Unit from Warwick.
So by memetic we mean info. Take info as a generic concept for now. Info that can replicate by itself a pattern is transmitted, copied and modified across different hosts, we say so the so-called memetic hyperstition begins when that info enters a feedback circuit and starts parasiting the infosphere.
So it doesn't need at all to take the form of a story or information. In the common sense of the term, anything really compressed works. So in this point we can separate it very well from new age manifesting. Because hyperstition in this way I'm explaining it is much closer to cybernetics than everything else.
It also is a process you can follow quite closely.
So hyperstition is autonomous in the sense that it doesn't need, it does not depend on anyone's belief. You see the term again belief. Here comes again the subject of enlightenment. Anyway, think this just as a computational movement.
Intelligence, for example, in this case can be approached as info that circulates and produces effects in a system. I'm not sure if you are familiar with the old goetic, magical Solomonic tradition that called demons intelligence. Solomon's grimoires.
Matthew Remski: Right, right.
Lucas Neckel: Hyperstition is a form, an interesting secularization of Solomon's concept of intelligence in my opinion. That's my point. So it is not really about manifesting in the same sense. Same sense as a wish fulfilling fantasy.
It is a circuit whose effects exceed the so-called subject.
I think now in my mind a good way to explain it is to say that hyperstition needs no superstition to work.
Matthew Remski: Oh wow, okay.
Lucas Neckel: You know, it works by itself. And do you want the best possible example of how memetic hyperstition can work? Work the mini manual.
We were using it to spread the mini manual.
That's why I said on Twitter it is a performative text because it circulates through this on premises.
So this is a good example, I think the best in hand for us.
Matthew Remski: Okay, let's continue with esoterica because one of the pieces that I fixated on was that you referenced Deleuze and Guattari and the influence of the face.
And so I'm wondering if you can walk us through that in this age in which it feels like the selfie is the predominant mode of self reflection and a kind of alienated communication.
Lucas Neckel: Do you know the Deleuze and Guattari got a lot of traction in Brazil actually, thanks to the public university.
So they are widely read and discussed we tend to import lots of French stuff.
So what we had in mind in this point was a chapter from A Thousand Plateaus on faciality.
Have you ever seen this online meme that goes something like, no, bro, I can't post your missing brother's poster on my feed. It would ruin my aesthetics. So your brother will stay missing. Sorry, I can't post it.
So like every good joke, this one is overflowing with truth.
The feed is created to preserve a coherent image and a coherence that can make even an urgent topic, even an urgent political topic, feel like a visual clutter.
So for sure, Deleuze and Guattari help us to think the selfie thing further.
For them, the face is produced by a machine of faciality.
They make this point in this book to the Christ face. You know, the white European face becomes the norm against which other faces are read, making, for example, racialized faces appear as deviations from the norm.
When they point to paintings, for example, they would analyze paintings that recast Christ as black or place a little black virgin at the edge of the frame, you know. So the machine of faciality is a system of recognition.
It decides what counts as a face or not, how much difference can be admitted.
And the selfie enters that system too.
We make our faces visible, but in forms that are already shaped by conventions of identity and recognition.
But here's the point. In the age of selfie, we have another kind of relation as operators, in a sense of this machine.
So the selfie is just a small part of this larger apparatus made of profile feed audience algorithm.
As we were saying before recording, I've been a victim of the low profile revolution myself. This is actually my first video in this profile.
So also, as we were saying, Janus has two faces.
This is a hint about the direction we were thinking and we will surely develop it further.
Iago Ribeiro: And again, the face is a way of bonding
Lucas Neckel: and
Iago Ribeiro: the face is a way of feeding the hyperstition because it has engagement potential, high engagement potential.
People like to to see faces and familiar faces.
Lucas Neckel: Look at my psychologist supporting Lula online. You know, it makes a little community around that. Look at my neighbor, look at my teacher,
Iago Ribeiro: my relative, whatever.
Lucas Neckel: Yeah,
Iago Ribeiro: it's bonding.
Lucas Neckel: He stood up for Lula.
Matthew Remski: I still don't know the name of the theorist that you named at the top of the show. The Brazilian who took up Lacan.
Iago Ribeiro: Magno Machado Dias or just Magno, Magno,
Lucas Neckel: Magno,
Matthew Remski: Magno. Just to return to the notion of the bond or what comes previous or ancient or prior.
It seems to me that the Facial and visual imprinting that we have between parents and babies, parents and infants is like a factor here.
Are we talking about that prior, that ancient, that fundamental.
Iago Ribeiro: That's part of
Lucas Neckel: it.
Iago Ribeiro: Imprinting is a very accurate term that you used, because that's the case.
The faces mark us deeply, especially these kinds of faces that are so deep wired for us.
This specific situation of being a baby that needs to be cared about for someone bigger.
And now this is symptomatically marking every one of us.
This kind of thing stays with us for our lives.
Lucas Neckel: And then language puts another layer to it, because, for example, just think at your given name. You are called to respond as Matthew. You know, we will discuss this topic in our forthcoming book through the Tragedy of Hamlet.
Hamlet, who is homonymous with his own father.
So he's always, like, intimated to respond as Hamlet.
It is a tragedy of the name, in some sense. You could sum up as that.
So we are thinking in this kind of way. You frame it very accurately, actually.
Iago Ribeiro: And your name ends up being the name of her face as well.
Lucas Neckel: Yes, exactly.
Matthew Remski: Is there a part of the influence of the face that is particularly salutary in the Brazilian context? In the sense that Lula's army is perhaps the most racially diverse political coalition in the world?
And when everybody, for instance, on that Saturday morning has put on the soccer jersey and they're flashing the L sign with their fingers, but there are white people and there are brown people, and there are black people, and there are very black people. Is there something additionally there that is generative in relation to what Deleuze and Guattari are pointing at?
Iago Ribeiro: Thank you. You touching a very important point about Brazil. Maybe not.
Maybe Deleuze and Guattari didn't think about it, but we certainly do.
And there is this point, there is no single face.
There is representative of the Brazilian face.
This is a fact that has a lot of psychic consequences to any Brazilian. So when you have multiple faces with multiple characteristics, of course it has more variety, it engages more, it brings more people. It's more hyperstitious in a way that how hyperstition may work in Brazil, in the Brazilian infosphere.
And I would say also that fundamental event in this second turn of our elections was when Lula opened his frontal camera for the first time and made a video.
Matthew Remski: Yeah.
Iago Ribeiro: When that happened, we knew that, wow, something is coming out of here. The face is important.
Matthew Remski: The fact that there is no Brazilian face.
Do you think that that provides some kind of organic defense against fascism?
Iago Ribeiro: I think it's complicated because There is no Brazilian face, but there are a lot of movements that try to fix what would be the ideal Brazilian face. Yeah, so this struggle is going on throughout our history,
Matthew Remski: right?
Iago Ribeiro: Which is the Brazilian face is the white face. The Brazilian face is the black face, the Brazilian face.
This is the profound part of our cultural landscape, of our political landscape.
Basically everything that is at play in Brazil passes goes through this kind of question.
This is a very profound thing for us actually.
But it's an open question.
Brazil is still happening and we do not see an easy resolution. For this
Matthew Remski: last question is beyond these short term electoral emergencies.
You had a very powerful strategy that faced a fork in the road, a binary problem over three weeks.
The strategies were developed before that, but applied within a very short term program.
What do you believe is the long term horizon for Janonism?
Iago Ribeiro: This electoral experience alone has already given us plenty of questions to work on.
And as Lucas said, we have already started doing it.
We are working in a full book.
The mini manual is very short form.
It was forged in the heat of that moment, you know, And I think we made the most of the timing. But now we have more time, more serenity to develop some theoretical aspects in more profound ways. But we also don't give to. Don't want to give too much away now.
But of course we'll keep observing what happens to Janonism now that it is an established communication force.
It is something now, not just an idea. And we are not campaigning anymore. So what will be of Janonism?
We don't know how this terrain is going to morph from now on.
Matthew Remski: It does appear to me that you have maybe not a series of controlled tests coming up, but with 24 translations and social movements erupting in various places in the world on different timelines, you'll be able to probably see various applications and how they unfold in real time.
Lucas Neckel: However, political parties everywhere in the world are adopting officially the manual. That is crazy. But I think something we can say about the political Horizon is that obviously we are not interested in simply getting better at playing the platform games.
Also, a very important thing to say is that platforms learn from our usage.
So the Arab Spring and Facebook cases are useful reminder. So any tactic that becomes effective may prompt a response from the platforms. So we have to keep adapting all the time. But as I've said, adaptation isn't the final goal. And we don't want Brazil to remain dependent, for example, on prevailed platforms that can decide what becomes visible or not. Our longer horizon is to challenge that power. Obviously regulate Big Tech, build digital sovereignty and ultimately sweep its dominance out of Brazil. Obviously that is on the scope.
Matthew Remski: Do you have insight as to whether or not, just by pure sort of economic and perhaps Marxist principles, whether or not the platforms would be able to compromise their algorithmic business models by suppressing the kind of virality that you are producing, going in this leftist progressive direction, they would have to be able to say, you know what, even though they have built an incredible vortex of attention and engagement, we are going to cut off our nose to spite our face.
We're going to have to put our thumb on the scale in a way that actually diminishes our business model.
That's, I think, what they would have to do. Do you have any thoughts on that?
Lucas Neckel: We have only China as an example for it. So it's very hard to think in any other level. I don't know what Iago thinks.
Iago Ribeiro: Yeah, it's a hard question because I was seeing how the results on these midterms, the US, the big tech guys are already making some, they are adjusting their political positions already.
These guys know how to adapt, know how to read where the process is going and adapting accordingly.
But in this case with Janonism and the spread of Janonism, what other countries, other movements will do out of it, I really don't know what will be their standard on this, how they will react, but certainly they will react.
Will they counter it? Will they try to include it in their machine of producing value?
I don't know. But we certainly have to be, have to be attentive.
Lucas Neckel: Attentive? I don't know.
Matthew Remski: Attentive? Yeah,
Iago Ribeiro: we have to be attentive to that. Of course.
Matthew Remski: Well, as the propaganda truck passes one more time by your window, Iago, it's time to thank you both for this incredible work that you've done. And then also by shedding your low profile life and revealing your names and faces to the world, I think it's an incredible intervention. And I know you both have a very humble disposition. I know that you come from an intellectual heritage that you value and that you refer to all the time and that you feel that you're standing on the shoulders of giants.
But also you have made really strong effort here and I really want to thank you personally for that because it's just rare to see these skills come together and then people having the passion to be able to go and make the thing occur, to actually push against the material world that way.
So I want to thank you for that and I hope you both keep safe. And I also Hope that we catch up later because I think I want to develop Janonism against Mark Carney, which is a longer term project.
But I might have you both back on to assess whether or not you think I'm making the right steps.
Lucas Neckel: Let's go.
Iago Ribeiro: You can count on us.
Lucas Neckel: Do you receive your certification from Lula's army? From. I did.
Matthew Remski: I did. But who sent it to me?
Did somebody make it?
Did one of you make it?
I've never heard of before.
Lucas Neckel: Comrade Nossa Senhora made it for you.
Matthew Remski: Oh, that's who it is. Oh, okay. You referred to her before in Mexico.
Iago Ribeiro: Yeah.
Matthew Remski: Oh, my God.
Yeah. No, I'm going to put it on my wall.
Lucas Neckel: So thank you very much for your. Thank you so much for your work with your podcast. It was a really good surprise for us also to know this space to talk on it, obviously, but also to see that there are things happening in Canada and other places. So it's a pleasure.
Iago Ribeiro: You are a kind of Internet godfather for the mini manual, you know that?
Lucas Neckel: Yeah.
Matthew Remski: Okay. I'm gonna put that shit on a T shirt and I'll talk to you soon. Take care of yourselves.
Lucas Neckel: You too, man.
Iago Ribeiro: Take care.
Lucas Neckel: Bye bye. Take care.
Matthew Remski: Now, before I let you go, I want to give a news update, but I want to begin by recalling Iago's comment off the top. He said, I would say that our allegiance lies more with Janus than with Janones at this point, but I'm a good soldier as well. And then I ask about Janus, and Iago says, janus means for us a metaphor of the mirror. The mirror whose logic is so important to think about the workings of the mind, the world, and of course, those of the platforms as well. Janus is the God with two faces. He's always looking in opposite directions at once.
And he's a good way to not personify Janonism too much. I think that what happened is much bigger than the man.
Now, as would be expected, there is an emerging conflict in Lula's army over questions of ideological commitment and honesty that flow out of a financial policy point that the Workers Party has had to navigate as they prepare to face a hostile Congress for Lula's term. At issue is a fiscal adjustment bill.
And army members opposed to it are using the scissors emoji sign, which signifies the big cut, which is a term they used against Flávio Bolsonaro's Javier Milei style cuts plan during the campaign. They're saying that Lula's package resembles the austerity he campaigned against. And some are leaving the channel and Janones is responding with characteristic zeal, blaming a bunch of radical extremists and apartment pseudo revolutionaries.
Now it's not clear how many folks are driving this criticism or who believe the Workers Party rationale that it must secure fiscal credibility amid rising debt, a weak real and war driven fuel costs which will open up room for rate cuts and funding promises before the hostile Congress.
Several hundred thousand people have either been persuaded that this is the wrong direction or they're not buying it themselves and they've left the channel. So I followed up with Iago and Lucas because all of this went down after our conversation. And their impression is that criticism of the financial adjustment is healthy. It's invited, it has always been something that they say to Lula has asked for, but that there is a concern that army allegiances can be too easily frayed by Janones algorithm tactics turned against him. And the detractors to this point now have their own WhatsApp channel. They're promoting an unnamed 2030 candidate. They're calling Lula a traitor and equating him with Flávio Bolsonaro. And so a tool built in the lead up to a single binary vote is now being tested in the stage of governance where the issue is a real policy disagreement amongst the government's own base and not in opposition to Bolsonaro. Iago notes that the channel's command structure has no real built in mechanism to navigate or absorb internal dissent.
And one source said that the conflict touches on painful echoes in Brazilian politics dating back to at least 2013 when similar conflicts eroded the left to the point that the right wing movement that gave rise to the Bolsonaro regime was able to rise.
Now, as an outsider, I'm not really surprised that a victory is now followed by conflict over its meaning, especially in this eternal realm of who is truly radical, who will compromise, who gives up too much in the name of reformism, who is committed to different speeds of change going back to Rosa Luxemburg. This is the perennial debate, but the question is whether, as Iago and Lucas have said, it can happen on platforms where deliberation has been crushed and anyone can attempt to exercise brute informational force.
All that said, I do agree with Iago that the theoretical and practical breakthroughs of this moment rise above the sausage making reality of how the struggle must continue.
But I want to end on a personal note because of all of the interviews I've done over the years, this is one of the most precious, I think, because I got to speak with young Brazilian psychoanalysts who make memes and called me bro and who have absorbed most of the same dusty books on Marxism and the Frankfurt School that I have. But at a moment in history in which things have never looked so bleak, they have animated those pages with chutzpah and Irish.
And they have watched that animation moved the needle of democracy and consciousness in a vast country of infinite faces watched over by a Black Madonna where mists rise over the forest that helps the planet breathe. It's so strange.
I almost feel like I've been there. And I suppose that's hyperstition for you.
Take care of each other.