Episode Transcript
Antifascist Dad Episode 57: What Students Accomplished in Serbia with Lav Mrenovic
Matthew Remski: Hello everyone, my name is Matthew Remski and this is episode 57 of Antifascist Dad podcast: What Students Accomplished in Serbia with Lav Mrenovic.
Lav Mrenovic: Authoritarian governments and this kind of like charismatic authorities appeal to the real insecurity of the people. And I think unless we, you know, like, I think the left critique of authoritarian government should first and foremost deal with the needs of the people.
Matthew Remski: You can find me on Bluesky and Instagram under my name and I'm on YouTube and TikTok as antifascistdad. And the Patreon for this show is antifascistdadpodcast, where subscribers get early access to a second weekly episode and in this case on the Wednesday after the midterm elections in the United States. I'm recording this before that, so I don't know what the results are.
This is that second episode and it will be behind the paywall to help to finance the show, but only for a while because this is an educational project and everything gets released quite quickly to the wild. If you'd like to support the show and the work that I do here, please consider any amount of subscription donation money to Patreon is very helpful and I really appreciate your support.
In your show notes for this episode you'll see all of the research links for the materials that are covered in this review of the situation in Serbia and you'll also find a link to my book called Antifascist Dad: Urgent Conversations with Young People in Chaotic Times. So you can pick up a copy of that if you haven't already. And again, if you're listening to this on Patreon on the day that it was released, I really thank you for your support.
So on the same day that I interviewed João Biondi about the Lula army in Brazil, I did a quieter interview with writer Lav Mrenovic who beamed in from Belgrade to flesh out the textures of a different slower burning revolution in self governance.
On October 25th. The decade plus dominance of former right wing soccer hooligan turned organized crime thug turned autocrat nerd Aleksandar Vučić ended when a decentralized democracy first student led political coalition nominated a diverse slate of non politicians that defeated Vučić's party of reactionary retreads and neoliberal flunkies a strong majority.
There are so many social movements popping off at the moment and I'm trying to create a syncretic picture of how they are working in their shared major themes and their minor regional differences.
In France, the manifs continue past Macron's first efforts to capitulate. In Portugal, Italy and Spain, the riot police are getting more aggressive. And beneath each of these stories lies a history of capitalist immiseration.
The the plundering contempt of private equity, leaders who chose their bankers over their people, and small triggering moments that unleash waves of fury that will either coalesce or they will disperse.
In France, it was rain coming through the roof of the school. In Spain, it was a single elderly woman evicted from her home of 70 years, who then died. In Portugal, it is a working class of the cities who, when the housing market was swallowed by private equity, suddenly couldn't afford the rent.
And I'm also seeing two old strategies, often opposed to each other, both breaking through in different parts of the world.
In Brazil, the propaganda strategy mobilized by André Janones depended on a short time frame in the critical task of defeating the fascist Bolsonaro mob at the polls. They called him a general, and he led a vanguard in a very Leninist method, a very democratic centralist method of digital warfare. But in Serbia, a leaderless, decentralized revolution took shape over two years. And so it feels like the communist model is winning in some places and the anarchist model is winning elsewhere.
So what triggered the Serbian wave? Well, we have to go back to November of 2024, when in Novi Sad, 100 kilometers northwest of Belgrade, the canopy over a new train station which had been opened and inaugurated by Vučić standing alongside Viktor Orbán a few months before.
And this train station was supposedly a symbol of Vučić's managerial prowess and technocratic savvy. The thing collapsed and it killed 16 normal people going about their normal lives.
And in dying, they exposed the lazy, venal neglect of the capitalist class who are happy to profit over endangerment.
Those 16 portraits on the front page seemed to shake a people awake to the fact that they can organize themselves, that they need not be depressed, that they are better and smarter and more caring and strategic than the leadership they have inherited from generations of men.
So I'll go through a little bit of a timeline here.
Aleksandar Vučić got his political start in 1993 in the far right Serbian Radical Party. He rose as a soccer hooligan organizer and has since kept these thugs close to him as political enforcers and contacts within the organized crime world. In July of 1995, in the days after the Srebrenica genocide, he honored his far right party by declaring, if you kill one Serb, we will kill 100 Muslims. But his eventual career as a center right technocrat has meant constantly putting a lot of distance between himself then and himself now.
But as Lav discusses in our interview, he's never fully disowned the hooligan persona, which conveys to his older supporters a kind of pragmatic street smarts, the knowingness about how things really work, how to get things done.
Now, in 1998, his party formed a government with the Socialist Party of Serbia and the Yugoslav Left.
And Vučić became Minister of Information and initiated what would become his favorite pastime of suppressing and centralizing the press.
The BBC notes that he was responsible for implementing some of Europe's most restrictive laws on freedom of speech. And there's an excellent commentary from Yugopnik on YouTube. I'll link to it in which he talks about how in the 2000s, this cashed out with you being able to flip between 15 channels on Serbian TV and all of them would be broadcasting the same banal speech Vučić was giving as he opened some new swimming pool in some rural town and patted himself on the back.
Now, as time went on, much of this media control was put into the service of ingratiating himself to the reactionaries of Europe while adopting a seemingly more centrist stance.
And after co founding the Serbian Progressive Party in 2008, he publicly renounced his previous ultranationalism and pledged to take Serbia into the European Union. Because I think that's where more of the money was.
Now, after the 2012 elections, Vučić is appointed Minister of Defense and then drifts over to first deputy prime minister.
In 2014, he becomes prime minister and in 2017, president.
He grows ties with the EU and the U.S. He deepens cooperation with China, Turkey and Russia. And he clamps down further on media and starts fudging elections and centralizing even more control.
Meanwhile, the ongoing erosion of the commons through the privatization measures started over a decade before were increasing inequality, acrimony and conflict throughout the country.
In May of 2023, there were back to back mass shootings that killed 18 people in under 48 hours.
Nine children included.
The Serbia Against Violence protests that followed were the largest since Vučić's party took power in 2012.
And in December of that year, international observers of the election reported vote buying and ballot box stuffing. Vučić blamed the unrest on foreign interference and dismissed all fraud claims. And then he used his electoral win to restore the lithium mining license of the British Australian mining giant Rio Tinto to plunder the Jadar Valley. And that triggered mass protests in multiple cities over environmental and water contamination concerns. Around 30,000 people marched in August.
Nonetheless, in October, the Vučić coalition rejected a law banning lithium mining and exploration.
Which brings us to November 1, 2024. 11:52 a.m., the newly reconstructed canopy of Novi Sad's railway station caves in. Sixteen people are killed, one more is severely injured.
And in the first weeks, the protests are mostly quiet vigils, like weekly 15 minute traffic blockades on Fridays at 11:52 a.m. On November 21, after a three day blockade of the prosecutor's office, detention was ordered for 12 people tied to the reconstruction, including former construction minister Goran Vesić. Vesić's detention was revoked about a week later. November 22, students and professors of the Faculty of Dramatic Arts in Belgrade were attacked while paying tribute to the victims.
And that was the direct trigger for the blockades formed by the faculty.
In late November, the blockade spread to public universities in Novi Sad, in Kragujevac, in Niš, in Novi Pazar, and other cities, and many high schools as well. On December 22, tens of thousands of students, farmers and citizens gathered at Slavija Square in Belgrade.
And then through the winter and spring, the crowds just grew to hundreds of thousands.
And Vučić resorts of course to police repression, including, get this, allegedly starting a stampede in March by activating a sonic cannon during a silent memorial for the train canopy 16.
This led to many, many injuries and of course a denial from Vučić that any sonic cannon was involved.
The escalations only continued. Vučić bemoaning the lack of Gandhi like nonviolence on the streets. If people only knew how to ask for things properly.
But out of the blockades, the emergence of student run plenums began to form. These are assemblies run on direct democracy, in which any student could raise an issue which would then be discussed and voted on.
And by May of 2025, the students have organized themselves enough to be able to call with one voice for snap parliamentary elections.
And they go and set up pamphleting stations across the country to talk about and collect signatures for that demand.
And they get the signatures that they need, but they don't form a party.
It's more like a citizens group that winds up selecting candidates through more than a year of assemblies and collective work and vetting processes.
The candidates go to faculty commissions who study them, they present themselves to the plenums and they take questions. And then the electoral commission of students votes on each candidate.
And so in August of 2026, there was a final vetting process where the plenums challenged 99 of the 300 potential candidates. And then in September, 38 candidates were cut from the list.
Now that final. So a very heavy primary process.
In other words, very thorough and very horizontally distributed.
The final list is headed up by a cardiologist, Ilija Srdanović.
They're a professor at the Faculty of Medicine in Novi Sad.
And that list has 250 candidates, mostly academics, experts and public figures. I heard there was a couple of oddballs in there too, like a rapper.
There were also 14 founders of the citizens group that was involved early on.
More than half of the candidates hold doctorates and no students appear on the list.
And the list is also ideologically diverse, as you might expect from an anarchistic process. And so I discuss all of that with Lav.
The campaign runs under the slogan Serbia or Mafia because the highlight is corruption, para police gangs and links between the state and organized crime.
Student List volunteers report visiting 170,000 households in 20 days on their door knocking runs. They set up stands in markets, in neighborhoods and villages.
They have an initiative called A Student in Every Village, which brought door to door visits to voters who just don't attend rallies.
Most opposition parties also stood aside to give the Student List a clear run.
And Vučić pulled out all the hooligan tricks. He labeled students foreign backed blockaders. So this is the old outside agitators thing.
I mean, guys have been using this for 100 years. And he created a fake pro government students group, because that's pretty funny.
So a bunch of paid actors who are like, no, we're the real students. We actually really do like this crappy system.
And this is our Facebook group. Join our Facebook group.
His people meddled in polling stations as well. And there are allegations that there was a planned forcible takeover or coup.
But eventually he lost 52.5% to 39.3%.
And of course he blamed media and foreign interference and not the fact that he's a washed up thug, or that his long suffering people found it within themselves to revitalize their civic consciousness.
And on that note, I was very moved to see little videos of the citizens of Belgrade out in the streets yesterday with buckets of white paint and rollers covering up the right wing graffiti of the Vučić gang.
So there are these little kids who are wearing raincoats, covered in paint, having a blast, wiping the slate of their beautiful ancient city clean.
So I'll run my conversation with Lav Mrenovic now, but I'm going to leave a few questions hanging that I'll be following up on.
The first is that the Student List really wiped out the legacy political class in Serbia. And good riddance, like, can you imagine cleaning house like that in the U.S., in Canada, in Australia.
And a lot of legacy parties such as the Socialist Party of Serbia, which is sclerotic, failed to meet electoral thresholds for party status.
I think what will be far harder to purge is the Vučić so called deep state, his dingleberry flunkies in the police, intelligence and military who might try to sabotage the transition and buy off student representatives.
Another hard task that Lav points to is ideological coherence and direction. The Student List did not accentuate partisanship in its primary focus on destroying the autocracy.
They foregrounded a universalist demand for democracy over the task of dismantling capital.
And I guess time will tell whether this structural revolution against corruption is also a revolution against the capital order.
Lav Mrenovic is a culture worker from Belgrade, Serbia, with an education in contemporary art history. He has been active in the independent cultural scene as a writer, editor, curator and organizer. Here's our conversation.
Lav Mrenovic, thank you so much for joining me on Antifascist Dad.
Lav Mrenovic: Thank you, Matthew. It's a pleasure to be here. And I want to thank you for reporting on this thing because we feel a lot of people actually feel here that it's still kind of under the radar of Western mainstream media.
Matthew Remski: I think it is.
So let's start by covering the initial conditions.
Vučić has or had been in power for how many years? And is it fair to really call him, I guess, the bastard neoliberal son of Milošević?
Lav Mrenovic: So basically 14 years ago there was a swing from, let's say centrist government to more of this center right in alliance with a bit of like far right actors in 2012, first at presidential elections and parliamentary elections which were held the same year. But then actually Vučić kind of like rose gradually after 2014 when he became first a prime minister and afterwards president.
I am personally careful with the comparisons to Milošević. To be honest, a lot of people do compare him.
But I think first of all, I think the whole context of it has been very, very different.
And I think that they are actually very quite different characters and models of authority. Milošević was ruling the country during the war, during the breakup of Yugoslavia.
These were the first years, the introduction of multi party system.
It was still very fresh and new. He actually it was during the 90s when the actual process, this gradual process of privatization of common ownership and public ownership happened. And generally it was like these were the years of triumphs of neoliberal globalization which Serbia and Milošević didn't really take part in maybe did actually they did in a way economically, but in sense of integrating into new global society, it didn't happen. I think the better comparisons are with the other who are usually called right wing populists within EU. The most usual comparisons are made with Viktor Orbán in Hungary or Robert Fico in Slovakia. But I think it's a really good reminder that Vučić party, Serbian Progressive Party is a member of European People's Party in EU, the the umbrella party of conservative parties within EU. So I think he's in a sense more a trend of this right wing populist that integrates part of the further right wing figures in minority positions. I think that he's a very agile and he's actually a very talented politician, how can I say managed to navigate the different political waters and he has been able to change himself and his political views.
So you know, I think he's also very eclectic in this sense of like all of his inspirations they are now in the past few years they have been really looking up to Trump. There are more and more connections with the MAGA, parts of conservative of Republican party. Sorry,
Matthew Remski: Right.
Lav Mrenovic: There are more and more meetings with them. So I think he's drawing inspiration from multiple sources, to be honest.
Matthew Remski: Now I've watched him so speak just to talk of his character for a moment. Of course I can't understand what he's saying, but I'm not getting the sense from his just his physical presentation of a lot of charisma. Am I missing something? Was there some charm that he had that allowed him to move in so many different ways over so many years?
Lav Mrenovic: Yeah, I think that that is actually a really great question and a question that I think a lot. I don't think that he's charismatic leader in this kind of like more let's say traditional in a way that we are mostly used to.
He has this kind of like boring nerd persona you don't necessarily find charming, but you can trust him in a sense that he really cares the image that he's selling. He really cares for the country, for the nation, for its people.
He has for example, these elements of this Max Weber's charismatic authority. He talks directly to the people against entrenched bureaucracy. He can offer often criticize lower level members of his party. He can be quite mean and he can say nasty stuff about them and he disciplines them. Or for example, when he goes around the country, when he's on his campaign tour, he sometimes encounters and there was like one very viral one during this campaign, he encounters some kind of like people who don't like him. And when there is this kind of like very awkward interaction, he's called afterwards these like local party members for like not caring for the people. And because there they don't. Since the bureaucracy party bureaucracy is not doing their job properly. This is kind of the situation which he ends up in. And he has this whole.
He has created this myth of a person who is like working overtime the whole time. He doesn't have a private life. He, you know, like, he.
So in this sense, you know, like. And he goes against this kind of character for corrupt, which is like a very archetype for like, let's say Serbia or Balkan, of this corrupt politician that he only cares for himself. He's extremely dedicated. On the other side, he has this from Milošević, end of Milošević's era and 2000s when he was much further, he was in the far right party, actually. He kind of has this kind of street credibility.
He was in the streets, he was a football fan, he was a far right nationalist. He said very extreme stuff, let's say. So there's this kind of like. Especially for maybe older voters and more conservative voters. He has this kind of like credibility, you know, like we know that he's from the streets, but now he's this like boring nerd that does get stuff done.
Matthew Remski: That's a very interesting profile, you know?
Lav Mrenovic: Yeah, yeah, I think it is. I mean, at least in the West, I don't know. I think he's this kind of like, very strange. He's not the usual right wing populist.
Matthew Remski: It sounds like he's able to evoke empathy from maybe his older followers. Like, oh, this guy's really working overtime and he's doing the best that he can. And if he wasn't here, then who would really sacrifice as much for the country, that sort of thing?
Lav Mrenovic: Yeah, yeah. And of course, I mean, there are limits to this whole persona and it has hit its limits, for example, with the whole corruption affairs, you know, like he could scold all of his members, I don't know, ministers, people on different positions. But then these people never ended up on court.
They were never on trial, nothing happened to them.
So you can maintain this kind of whatever kind of image up to a certain point. And then it hits the wall.
People see through it. So I think this is something that has happened.
Matthew Remski: Well, speaking of corruption, perhaps the catalyzing event is the collapse of this train station two years ago which killed 16 people, civilians. Why was this the final straw or a spark for a kind of uprising against Vučić?
Lav Mrenovic: I think this is actually a very, very difficult question. I think it is going to get an answer actually in years to come when things get properly researched. I can say a bit maybe from my personal memory, which is of course like clouded. It's unreliable and like, colored by my personal life. But like, I felt like there were a couple of years, I think from 2023 until. Yeah, maybe.
Depends how you want to count it. But I think there were a couple of years of kind of like, I would name it, like collective political depression.
The collapse of this roof or canopy of the train station kind of was. I think it was just like a very triggering event that kind of evoked the whole society. I don't think that I can, you know, like, there, of course, like, there were certain factors, like, you know, oppositional political parties were not really representing people's voices, people's needs.
So there is of course a reason of why student movement appeared in the first place. You know, like the oppositional party didn't do their job properly. So I think it's kind of just. It was this kind of like a rift in time and space that like, the whole society realized that it needs, like, networks of care, of solidarity, that they need to be there for each other. So I don't know. Unfortunately, I cannot describe it other than some kind of like, miracle. But like, I think we are going to get a proper sociological explanation in the years to come. But like, I
Matthew Remski: mean, we're talking about a small country where 16 people in the portraits on the page, on the front page of the newspaper, who. They were just in a train station, which is this very normal thing to do to get around the country. This is your daily life.
And it's obvious that the collapse of the roof is the result of just years and years of mismanagement and false promises and poor construction and people skimping on money and pocketing things.
So I guess it just seems like a very simple, straightforward tragedy that is so riveting to this small country.
Lav Mrenovic: You are absolutely right, Matthew.
I would maybe even add that. I think the reason why it echoed so hard is that because a lot of Vučić's promises is this kind of like developing of infrastructure, which actually a lot of happened, it is true. But what this collapse, I think kind of destroyed this whole image that it's just good, nice development of infrastructure. So it kind of destroyed this myth and showed that there is underlying corruption, lack of care, lack of. We are talking about, like, control, construction, control. It is yet to actually really go through courts. So we are actually going to one day get to know actually all of the stuff.
Matthew Remski: Yeah. Find out where the money went or who didn't complete which regulatory test and that sort of thing.
Lav Mrenovic: Right. So the scale of it is yet to be seen. We know certain things from whistleblowers, from, I don't know, gossip, from investigative journalism, but these are all pieces.
So if it gets properly investigated in the next period, we are actually going to know the scale of the whole thing.
Matthew Remski: The scale of the whole thing is really probably going to be the scale of the slow eroding process of neoliberalism itself. When I think about catalyzing events for the manifestation in Paris right now, in France, we're talking about, like, schools that were neglected for 10 years and kids reporting that, you know, when I started here in the ninth grade, there was rain coming in through the corner of the room into a garbage pail. And when I graduated five years later, the rain was coming through the roof into the garbage pail. And at a certain point, conditions converge where these very banal signs of neglect, which actually amount to a kind of contempt for people, they just become too much for enough people to bear. And then things get rolling.
Lav Mrenovic: You are completely right. Yeah. It is an accumulation of years and years of dissatisfaction with numerous things from corruption. They were like Rio Tinto mining was supposed to happen, lithium mining, normalized violence in public sphere. There were like years and years of affairs, of scandals, of dissatisfaction, a lot of stuff. So I also want to highlight that for years there were many people that were fighting, that were documenting all of these things, that were writing about it, doing investigative journalism that did activism, years of dissatisfaction and years of work of, for the lack of a better term, maybe raising consciousness.
Matthew Remski: I think that what's extraordinary about the emergence of the Student List, which we'll get to now, is that one of the characteristics of neoliberal governance throughout the world, I think, is this pervasive feeling that not only is nobody really in control, right. Not only is nobody really taking care of infrastructure or social programs, but that there's no real sense of collective possibility. There's no real sense of being able to work together towards something. And, you know, that's a function of the decline in unions, the decline in, you know, third spaces. You know, I don't know what's happened in Serbia with regard to things like, you know, civic organizations like choirs or, you know, gardening associations or things like that, because, you know, in North America, for example, the experience over the last 40 years has been that generally people do not find themselves doing cooperative things very often.
And so when something like the Student List comes together, it seems to be like the regeneration or the revitalization of something that has been lost for a long time and people all deciding, oh, wait a minute, that we're not actually individuals scrolling on our phones anymore. We can actually do something together.
Lav Mrenovic: You're absolutely right. In that sense. This is what I'm saying. It's in a sense kind of a miracle of, you know, like, of course it's not a sudden, it took months, you know, just. I'm talking just like very about like student movement of building these networks of solidarity.
I would generally characterize. I think that is a really big difference, for example, in comparison to United States, from the scale of the country, the population, the geography.
I think there is like much more of a communitarian spirit, I will put it like that way.
In general Balkans and southern parts of Europe, so, you know, like people hang out a lot, people help each other a lot. People care about their families, their neighbor, their neighbors. I don't want to paint any kind of rosy or utopia, communist utopia picture. It's not like that.
Matthew Remski: But you still have villages, correct?
Lav Mrenovic: Yeah, but Serbia is like, it's no different than any other country in this terms of globalization and people moving to the cities for better work. And this is something actually in Serbia that has been going on since the Second World War and it has just intensified with the neoliberal globalization. So people are actually moving to the bigger cities. We do have villages, but like there are very few and less and less younger people.
Matthew Remski: Right,
Lav Mrenovic: but I'm talking more about this sense of like, let's put it that way, like everyday living. But it's kind of like a very, how can I say, a redefinition of all of these like relationships within the society. So I think, I think it's now much more. There is much more solidarity, help care for each other.
And I think people are actually really feeling hopeful after a really long time.
And I think these are all political emotions which are important for any movement or any real or more profound political change.
Matthew Remski: And participants in the Student List, they really walked the walk because as I understand it, from the beginning, all decision making was collective. And I mean, did that happen through in person meetings, through councils? Did people share Google Docs around as they were working on various things?
Lav Mrenovic: It emerged from this very, what we call like plenum, which could be translated as popular assembly. But it was actually in the, the first phase limited only to universities, faculties within the university. So each faculty within all of the universities in Serbia had their own assembly and they were making decisions collectively. And then they were like it translated on higher and higher levels within the city than cities, in between cities.
And then afterwards, this kind of model of, of the direct democracy, it kind of spread to the citizens, mostly organized around locales, so basically their municipality, what would be translated as municipality.
Matthew Remski: Right.
Lav Mrenovic: And their citizens were talking, you know, like they were making decisions, they made actions, they were talking about their own problems, etc. There was communication between citizen assemblies and student assemblies.
There were certain attempts in different sectors, mostly in culture. But there is also a revival of trade union independent. Mainly this is a very important thing, independent trade union activity, as trade unions exist. In trade unions, the biggest ones didn't properly support people that went on strikes in support of students.
So it was mainly in public elementary schools and high schools that independent trade unions, they were newly founded, basically, or they went against. They were happening within the trade union, but against the directives from the center. So it's kind of like a confluence of all of these things going on. It's kind of a draft idea that I have currently, but I think it's at least for Serbia really. First through post pandemic movement that actually really intensified in person communication, decision making, etc. Although of course technology is inseparable part from creating basically propaganda to communicating to communication within the movements and assemblies.
So Internet really played a significant part. We it cannot be overlooked.
Matthew Remski: The list itself is a function of Serbian Parliament, where I understand that you have to nominate like a full roster of candidates all at once. Correct. And it's over 200. Am I right about that?
Lav Mrenovic: Yeah. So there are 250 seats in the parliament, national parliament. All the major parties always nominate for 250 candidates. And it is a closed list list. So the people that you nominated, they are entering the parliament in that specific order.
So currently Student List won 141 seats, which is Progressive Party, 103 if I'm not mistaken. And there are a couple of seats for minorities. Of course, 125, 26 is needed for 2526 is needed for majority. So Student List has couple a absolute majority.
Matthew Remski: And to throw off the supposed, I guess, the legacy of corruption and bureaucracy, the Student List chooses candidates who are academics, who are not students themselves necessarily.
But I'm wondering, I mean, first of all, they're not politicians and that seems to be a key factor in their reputation as it played out through the campaign, is that right?
Lav Mrenovic: You know, like, I think that for years there has been an entrenched kind of despise towards the political class itself among the people. And this is kind of like a very normal, even for a lot of the voters for the ex ruling party. You know, like people do say in the streets, kind of formalized, hey, all the politicians are corrupt, you know, like, so there's I think, I would say very strong distaste towards the political class. So in this sense, none of the people who were nominated by Student List, they cannot be considered a part of political class.
Matthew Remski: Right.
Lav Mrenovic: Some people were more. I mean these were all people who were in smaller or bigger scale, outspoken people, critics of the regime, but they were not high ranking members of any of oppositional parties. Maybe they had a short collaboration with them.
Some of the people we have not seen before in this sense politically. So it's kind of like a very mixed bag of white collar workers.
It is mostly intellectuals, a lot of people. I see now that there are some social media posts praising the number of PhDs in, in Serbian parliament now. Right.
But there are also people who are not in this sense, like they're not academics, they're some like farmers, cultural workers, activists.
Matthew Remski: Well, I guess my question about that is, if it begins as a student led movement, was there an issue with, you know, selecting or nominating these parliamentarians generally being older than students themselves, was there an issue in the perception of, oh well, the students are handing this over to an older professional class?
Lav Mrenovic: Maybe it could be mentioned as a critique, but extremely rarely.
The student movement still has its autonomy.
It has just for the needs of taking the power and for the needs of national parliamentary elections, nominated a set of people.
And I think that there were a lot of critiques initially towards the Student List, as they are this inexperienced youth that is kind of a bit maybe barbaric, anarchic, whatever, however you want to call it, disorganized, you know, so like, and Vučić has this kind of, like he has this image of kind of, you know, a person who gets stuff done. This kind of. He has this, I wouldn't call him a technocrat, but he, he took over this kind of like technocratic appeal.
So you know, like they were often accused them of their inexperience, wild kids.
So I think students had to solve this thing in one way. So they proposed the people with experience, maybe not necessarily in this kind of like strictly defined professional political experience, but experience in different fields. So there's like really all of the major fields are covered actually, within the Student List there are people from all of the different spheres of life.
And it is their proposal of experienced, mature people that can take over the state and handle the state. But student movement remains autonomous and we are going to have presidential elections by the end of the year. A Student List is also going to nominate somebody. But we are yet we. You know, in the next period it is going to get crystallized how exactly the relationship between the student movement and parliamentarians is going to be. I feel like it's going to be. I feel like right now it seems to me that Student List is kind of like an overseeing body to make sure the cohesion, cohesion and staying on track with the political program that they all jointly decided upon. So there is a program that candidates, future parliamentarians have to follow through.
Matthew Remski: Vučić tried everything to break this movement. I'm wondering if you can run down some of his strangest attempts and gambles.
Lav Mrenovic: I think that the key mistake is this is what Slavoj Žižek referred to in one essay very early in support of Serbian student movement. He said that which is basically did this clinch thing when in boxing, an opponent takes over the opponent and doesn't allow him to hit. So he first dealt the initial scandal was like that he basically used pure physical violence by his thugs who beat up the students, which was a catalyst for actually the first blockade or occupation of university that afterwards spread to the other faculties and universities.
So it was basically just pure physical violence. Different kind of attacks, smear campaigns, threats.
And then as the movement spread and at the moment where it actually involved the whole, went through the whole all pores of Serbia society, he was then putting a lot of pressure in all spheres of lives. You know, like actually mostly at work, people's workplaces, but like also afterwards in media attitude that is very hostile in the beginning and afterwards he called for a dialogue, but, you know, like, so, you know, like, I think that my kind of opinion is that he kind of like really intensified his personal and his party politics and a need for allegiance.
He brought it in every pore of everyday, like of everyday life. And I think it actually really tired people.
You know, now when I interpret all of these like celebrations, people talking about how they're feeling free,
Matthew Remski: right?
Lav Mrenovic: People were really actually tired and they were like suffering. Maybe it's not the biggest suffering ever. You know, people really feel. Felt tired from all of this thing, all of this plays, all of this pressure.
So I think, you know, like even from myself and seeing people, I think people are really feeling kind of like a strong sense of relief.
Matthew Remski: The Student List movement used many, many tactics. And I'm wondering what you think worked, what didn't, and what evolved along the way.
Lav Mrenovic: Student movement, I think, showed throughout the whole process a kind of, like, agility and kind of maturity. And maybe I would highlight this maturity in the light of all of this wave of youth rebellions across the Europe, I don't know, Albania, Italy, Spain, France, notably Germany.
So in the light of this thing, I would say that what Serbian student movement managed to do is kind of move beyond this.
I don't mean this in a bad way. Maybe destructive or antagonistic or anarchic.
Just displaying your dissatisfaction. Maybe it was in the first days after the collapse of this roof station, and there is still people are.
A lot of people feel very dissatisfied. They have a need to let their emotions out. Serbian student movement managed to very quickly show maturity and kind of like, graduate and take its thing to a next level to become kind of like, more constructive, to create these networks around the whole society, to visit the previously mostly opposition parties, parts of Serbia that actually none of them or most of the opposition parties actually didn't care, didn't show up for them. So students managed to walk throughout the whole Serbia to show that, to meet people, to talk with people.
And throughout it, through all of these walks that you mentioned, there were these networks of solidarity. People in smaller towns who, mind you, live with very limited or fewer resources.
They would bake, I don't know, pastry or cakes or, I don't know, put up drinks, refreshments for them, water, lemonade, whatever it may be, coffee, whatever it may be. So it created all of these bonds around the whole country.
So I think through all of this creation of all of these networks, it managed to be a constructive force and a mature force and a force that is ready to take over the state, and that shows that it cares for its population.
So I think that was a growth, and I think it's kind of like, actually, historically speaking, at least I can talk, at least for Western democracies, modern democracies. This is an unprecedented thing, especially for the type of what we are calling student movement, or wider sense of any kind of huge rebellion.
This is an unprecedented, how can I say, process of maturity and growth of this movement, I think. And it shows what this parliamentary result show is, that it actually can be successful. I mean, there's a long and difficult path yet ahead, probably much more difficult than what was before, to be honest, in my opinion.
But we can now say this model, this type of stuff, of course, it cannot be replicated exactly the same, but this thing works.
Matthew Remski: I imagine that part of the struggle going forward is going to be about clarity and commitment and ideology. Because I understand that the movement, the Student List, was quite insistent on at least the appearance of or the presentation of non partisanship and avoiding very strong polarizing distinctions between leftist politics and centrist or right wing politics. That just was not part of the discourse. But how will that cash out now? Because I think, you know, the reality is that this was an insurgency movement against a right wing government that had a long track record of right wing skullduggery. And we know that populism can veer in any direction when it takes power. And so I'm wondering whether you think the politics that drove this democratic movement will clarify in time and what will happen when that happens.
Lav Mrenovic: I mean, of course, I actually have a boring, as a trained art historian, boring answer. We don't know. We cannot predict history, especially as this thing is actually we don't have a historical reference.
But for now, I think student movement and Student List has a program upon which everybody agreed upon. I personally would characterize that program as kind of like a mixture of soft social democracy and soft culture, cultural conservativism, but like very like even much more soft than the social democratic aspects. But maybe I would actually refer and suggest even to people like everybody, like very early on, I think in the beginning of 2025, Žižek published this essay on, I think Project Syndicate. And I think it was titled The New Face of Protest, if I'm not mistaken. And he claimed that the Serbian student movement is radical because it demands the change of basic rules of the political game.
Matthew Remski: Right.
Lav Mrenovic: So maybe, you know, like according maybe to.
There are certain people on the left here, maybe even internationally, who are like. Vincent Bevins, also in London Review of Books wrote and wrote a diary from following student protests. And he has this now, I think, quite famous book, If We Burn, which is a critique of this kind of leader, leaderless horizontal movement. So there is now a case which kind of like for now, proves him wrong.
We'll see.
So unlike, I don't know, some people on the left who maybe who are kind of like more skeptical of this, like how radical this movement is. I think it is radical in this sense that like the basic rules of the game, of the whole political game are now changed. You know, like they are no more like this corruption hidden behind the closed doors parts of the rules.
Matthew Remski: There's a real feeling I get of almost like a direct democracy approach, where the candidates of the Student List are well known to those who nominated them. They are not political insiders.
They might actually be responsible to their constituents and that the process by which they communicate horizontally and make their decisions is actually transparent. It can be seen.
Lav Mrenovic: Exactly. You're right. I think that there is a lot of like. And maybe we can. I would like maybe to bridge this thing on this term of like populism. Like, you're right. I think it is that actually this whole thing is a radical experiment in radical democracy. Of course there were like parts.
Not going to say parts. Like there were phases when it was like more democratic, especially initially.
There are phases when it became less democratic for the needs of parliamentary elections. And I think that is actually fair thing. We'll see where this radical democratic spirit is going to return now after the elections. But I think people are really hopeful, engaged. I
Matthew Remski: think you're pushing back against me using the word populism. And you might be right in the sense that there is a populism of.
We all agree that the elite bureaucracy that's full of corruption must be overturned, but it's not populist in the sense that single issues are put forward as the content of the program.
You're talking about really the regeneration of the process of government.
Lav Mrenovic: Yeah, exactly. And returning the public institutions back to democratic processes. I think that is actually quite. I mean, radical.
My personal.
I mean the term populism has been contested in the past few, in the last decade or so intensely. I personally use. I'm mostly close. How can I say? I'm personally close to the term. How Ernesto Laclau and Chantal Mouffe use it. So in this sense, I would call this student movement actually case. Not maybe exactly textbook as how especially Chantal Mouffe articulates it.
But I think it is a case of left wing populist movement and a successful one so far.
I know some people, a lot of people are not fans of Laclau-Mouffe. I personally am, but I think it's not. I just don't want to get into this trap of this kind of liberal interpretation of populism as something necessarily right wing or damaging to liberal institutions
Matthew Remski: or vulnerable to capture. Vulnerable to capture or to veer in any direction. Yes.
Lav Mrenovic: So right now it's a leaderless movement. It is actually very decentralized still.
So I don't think that there is. Right now there is a fear of the one single person capturing. And I think that is actually why people voted it in the first place. There was a sense like student movement, this whole process and the way they did it and the way it was decentralized. People know that any decision went through numerous heads.
Many people were consulted about it, that were not only in Belgrade, that were not part of political class, that it's not one person. So it says like, like people feel secure about it.
Matthew Remski: Do you feel that maybe this is my last question, that Serbian culture has just also decided that it is tired of singular personalities and strongmen
Lav Mrenovic: right now? Definitely, yes. I mean, this is a decisive vote of enough though. I don't know, I don't want to be naive.
There were many historical examples, notably, I don't know, France or like with Napoleon and his 100 days.
Authoritarian governments and this kind of like charismatic authorities appeal to the real insecurity of the people. And I think unless we, you know, like, I think the left wing critique of authoritarian government should first and foremost deal with the needs of the people.
Of course we know that it is all fake and it is all like that they are not actually going to fulfill people's needs. We all like know this, every case is that. But we should be concerned with this thing. So I think what student movement also managed to do is actually really get this, really translate the needs of people into some kind of like viable political organization and people that can take over the country. So hopefully this collective endeavor will continue and it is going to take over this technocratic appeal of a lot of these authority figures that they can get stuff done. I think this is also a very important thing for any left wing movement to rise up to this point that we can.
I think this is also a lot of appeal of Zohran Mamdani in New York. Like he's a person that can get stuff done.
We are not going to end up in some debates, some constitutional law crisis or whatever. We know how to get basic stuff for Serbia. Right now it is returning the. Changing the political, the rules of the whole political game and returning the public institutions back to democratic rule. And I think these are radical. There is a very strong mandate for student candidates, future parliamentarians to do this thing right now. It seems that it is going to be done in the long term. I don't think anybody can or I don't think anybody should predict anything, but it is going to be actually a very difficult road towards this thing.
I don't have any illusions and I don't want to spread any kind of like false positivity about this thing.
It is going to be a very tough road.
Matthew Remski: Lav Mrenovic. Thank you so much for taking the time.
I'll get in touch with you. I hope that we stay in touch so that I can continue to understand what's happening.
Lav Mrenovic: Yes. Thank you, Matthew, for having me. Thank you for reporting on this thing.
Yeah.
Matthew Remski: So thank you again to Lav Mrenovic for the great on the ground view from Serbia.
And I'll be following up because it'll be very interesting to see what happens in the coming months.
And it's a happy sign off this week because there was good news in Brazil, there's good news from Belgrade.
And I'm recording this on November 3rd while the Americans were at the polls. And I think there will be some good news from the US. And I think it is worth remembering that these modest but very necessary gains in social democracy through the flawed electoral process, that as they take root and give some breathing space, there's still a difficult and dangerous road toward doing what neither Lula, nor the Democrats nor the Student List is probably able to do in an electoral sense, which is to really cut to the root of capitalism.
So my hope is that this exercise of democracy, this marking of X's, really unleashes all of the imagination and rule breaking thinking that we're going to need for the times ahead.
Take care of each other, everybody.